Federal Sentencing Guidelines for Drug Trafficking Offenses
June 21, 2023

Insider Trading Allegations: Legal Strategies for the Accused

By Hager & Schwartz, P.A.

September 26, 2023

Insider trading is when someone uses confidential, material information about a publicly traded company to decide to buy or sell its stock or other securities. This "inside information" is information that the general public doesn’t have access to. It could affect the company’s stock price if it were public knowledge.

“Insiders” are the people who typically have access to this inside information, such as officers, directors, and stockholders who own more than 10% of the company’s shares. Still, any employee with access to confidential data and details could also be insiders. Additionally, the term "insider" can include people who aren’t directly connected to the company but received tips from those who are, such as friends or family members.

Being accused of insider trading is a serious matter. You could face federal charges and if convicted, the penalties are harsh. These can range from paying significant fines to serving time in prison. Even the accusation alone can tarnish your reputation and affect your career, which makes it crucial to take immediate action if you find yourself in such a situation.

This blog post aims to offer guidance on legal strategies that could be employed if you’re accused of insider trading. While the article provides valuable insights, consulting a criminal defense lawyer experienced in handling federal crimes is essential for personalized advice and representation. Legal strategies must be tailored to the specifics of your case, and a seasoned attorney can help navigate the complex legal landscape.

If you are facing allegations in Fort Lauderdale, consider reaching out to Hager & Schwartz, P.A. by calling (954) 840-8713.

Understanding Insider Trading Laws

Understanding the laws related to insider trading is essential for anyone facing such allegations. It helps grasp the gravity of the situation and assists in determining possible courses of action. Legal intricacies must be fully understood to form an effective defense strategy.

One of the primary regulations dealing with insider trading is 17 CFR § 240.10b5-1. This regulation provides guidelines on what counts as trading "on the basis of material nonpublic information" in insider trading cases. Understanding this regulation is key to knowing what legal boundaries exist and what actions might lead to allegations of insider trading.

For someone to be convicted of insider trading, four main elements need to be present:

  • The defendant received information about a company.
  • The information was material, meaning it was significant enough to affect an investor’s decision to buy or sell the stock.
  • The information was not publicly available. In other words, it was "inside information."
  • The information influenced the investor’s decision to either buy or sell the company’s stock or securities.

Role of the SEC in Insider Trading Cases

The Securities and Exchange Commission, or SEC, is the federal agency responsible for overseeing and enforcing federal securities laws. When it comes to insider trading, the SEC plays a critical role. It investigates allegations and can bring a civil lawsuit against individuals suspected of engaging in insider trading. This is in addition to criminal charges that individuals may also face.

Potential Penalties for Insider Trading

The penalties can be severe and life-altering if you’re found guilty of insider trading. Understanding the range of potential consequences you may face if convicted is crucial.

Criminal Penalties

On the criminal side, insider trading can result in a maximum prison term of up to 20 years. Additionally, you could face a hefty fine, which can go up to $5,000,000.

A criminal conviction can lead to imprisonment and financial hardship and severely tarnish your reputation, affecting future employment and personal life.

Civil Sanctions

In addition to criminal penalties, you may also face civil sanctions. Civil penalties can include a fine of up to three times the profit gained or losses avoided due to insider trading activities. This means that if you obtained $100,000 in profit, you could be fined up to $300,000.

The concept of "disgorgement" also comes into play, where you may be required to give up any profits gained or losses avoided due to insider trading. This deterrent ensures that individuals don’t profit from illegal activities.

The Importance of Legal Representation

In insider trading cases, the legal complexities are often high, making the role of a competent criminal defense attorney crucial for your defense. The intricate web of laws, regulations, and evidence can make it challenging for someone without legal insights to navigate the situation effectively.

For instance, proving that trading was not influenced by material, nonpublic information can involve reviewing various documents, financial reports, email correspondence, and more. Failing to manage these complexities properly can result in severe penalties, including fines and imprisonment.

Legal Strategies for Defense

When faced with insider trading allegations, you have several legal avenues to explore in your defense.

Defense attorneys commonly use the following strategies to challenge accusations and protect their clients’ interests.

Challenge the Evidence Presented by the Prosecution

One of the first steps in forming a defense is to critically examine the evidence that the prosecution plans to use against you. While the prosecutor might see the evidence in a light unfavorable to you, a defense attorney can dig deeper to reveal facts that counter the prosecutor’s arguments.

This could involve:

  • Highlighting inconsistencies
  • Revealing the lack of a reliable source
  • Questioning the legality of how the evidence was obtained

The goal is to present an alternative narrative that puts the evidence in a different context, weakening the prosecution’s case.

Question the Intent Behind the Trading Activity

Another critical aspect of your defense involves questioning the intent behind your trading actions. The prosecution must prove that you traded based on material, nonpublic information. If your attorney can show that your trading decisions were made based on publicly available information or factors unrelated to the insider information, it can cast doubt on whether you engaged in illegal insider trading. If the intent to misuse inside information is not clearly established, the accusations may not hold.

Motion to Dismiss Based on Lack of Evidence

In some cases, the evidence the prosecution presents may not be strong enough to meet the burden of proof required for a conviction. If your attorney determines this, they may file a motion to dismiss the charges against you.

Similarly, procedural mistakes made during the investigation or improperly filed charges can also be grounds for dismissal. It’s crucial to scrutinize every detail, as even minor issues can significantly impact the outcome.

How a Lawyer Can Help Strategize

A skilled criminal defense attorney takes on the demanding task of scrutinizing all aspects of your case. This involves doing the necessary footwork, like collecting evidence, reviewing documents, and investigating the facts surrounding the allegations. Once they thoroughly understand the matter, they can determine a practical legal strategy.

It’s crucial to take steps to protect your rights and future as early as possible. Act now by contacting Hager & Schwartz, P.A. at (954) 840-8713 to schedule a consultation with a member of our Fort Lauderdale team.